Are Collectibles Allowed in an IRA?
The tax code specifies which investments can and cannot be included in an individual retirement account. Impermissible investments include collectibles and life insurance.
The IRS lists artworks, rugs, antiques, metals, gems stamps stamps alcoholic beverages and certain coins as items which cannot be held within an IRA account and that using retirement funds to purchase such items will constitute a distribution.
Artwork
IRC only stipulates what can or cannot be included in an IRA; custodians and brokers often impose further restrictions. For instance, although IRS allows an IRA to invest in real estate investments, many custodians won’t allow self-directed IRAs to hold rental property.
Additionally, certain investments must comply with IRS rules regarding prohibited transactions and unrelated business income tax (UBIT). If an IRA engages in such prohibited transactions or contributes UBTI, its favorable tax treatment could be affected.
Prohibited transactions for an IRA account include purchasing a vacation home for use by either the IRA owner or their family; purchasing stock from companies where the IRA owner serves as an officer or has a controlling interest; investing in life insurance contracts that do not fall under small employer plans; foreign investments should be limited to American depository receipts and domestically sponsored mutual funds; prohibited collectibles include artworks, rugs or antiques as well as metals such as gold, silver and rare coins as well as stamps or alcohol beverages.
Coins
Metals dealers sometimes sell collectible coins alongside bullion in order to attract investors with tales of rarity and high returns, however this exposes an IRA account to more risk as such coins are valued based on their numismatic value – rather than raw metal content.
Investors purchasing these coins face risks of IRS noncompliance should they later realize they were neither rare or desirable as imagined, nor will buyers pay the premium they imposed for these coins. They may also experience difficulty selling them without incurring further premium payments themselves.
One way to sidestep this issue is to donate collectibles directly to charity instead of investing them through an IRA, though this requires careful planning with a tax professional. In certain circumstances, investing certain collectibles through a charitable remainder trust (CRT) might also be possible but is usually more complex and should be discussed with an expert before being decided upon.
Wine & Liquor
IRS rules do not permit collecting items like art works, rugs and antiques; metals and coins; stamps and valuable documents; alcoholic beverages to be invested in an IRA. There are however, a few notable exceptions. IRAs may invest in precious metals that meet specific metallurgical standards while some coins (provided they meet specified metallurgical standards) and bullion investments are allowed as investments within an IRA.
If your Self-Directed IRA invested in one of these illegal collectibles, it would be considered a distribution and incur tax liability including early withdrawal penalties of 10% depending on age of account holder. Therefore, when making investments outside the typical realm of investments it’s advisable to consult an experienced tax professional so they can ensure your transaction does not violate rules against self-dealing and prohibited transactions and provide peace of mind that your IRA is in safe hands.
Gems & Diamonds
Are You an Investor Looking to Add Rare Gems and Diamonds to Your Portfolio in a Self-Directed IRA? As it stands now, the IRS prohibits this form of investing as it wants retirement investors to concentrate their funds in more stable assets such as bonds or annuities.
Good news is that the IRS permits certain precious metals to be held within a Self-Directed IRA, including gold, silver and platinum bullion coins and bars as well as numismatic gold and silver medals – provided they meet specific criteria such as purity, cut, clarity and carat weight.
Tax rules prohibit an IRA from selling or trading collectibles directly or indirectly to disqualified persons, and purchasing collectibles from these disqualified parties would constitute prohibited transactions with an early distribution penalty of 10% on any amount spent for these purchases. Therefore, be mindful not to sell or trade precious metals contrary to tax regulations.
Categorised in: Blog