Are Self Directed IRAs a Good Idea?

Are selfdirected IRAs a good idea

Self-directed IRAs allow investors to invest in assets not normally found in traditional brokerage accounts, such as real estate, precious metals and private companies.

However, it’s essential that you adhere to IRS regulations regarding these investments if you wish to invest in them legally and avoid penalties such as taxes or early withdrawal. Failing to do so could incur significant taxes or early withdrawal charges that will need to be paid upon withdrawal from an account.

Tax-Free Growth

Self-directed IRAs enable investors to take control of their retirement savings by selecting investments that match their interests, knowledge, and expertise – plus the added advantage of tax-free growth and withdrawals in retirement.

Before diving in headfirst, make sure that you understand all of the rules pertaining to self-directed IRAs. Certain assets cannot be purchased or managed by your IRA account and if any rules are broken the IRS could close your account as well as charge penalties and taxes against it.

Example: Buying property through your IRA for personal use like vacations would violate its rules. Furthermore, providing services (fixing that broken toilet, for instance) would constitute a prohibited transaction and is therefore illegal.


By investing through a self-directed IRA, you can build up your retirement nest egg with real estate and other nontraditional investments not generally offered through traditional IRAs – potentially leading to higher returns and providing for an easier retirement.

However, being responsible for selecting and reviewing investment opportunities as well as making informed decisions and avoiding prohibited transactions can be daunting for new investors. Furthermore, scam artists frequently target those using self-directed IRAs, so be wary of new investments with no track record, claims of unreasonable returns and no third-party oversight as red flags to watch out for.


Self-directed IRAs offer investors more control over their retirement savings with greater investment freedom and fewer restrictions, but with greater risk. Investors need to carefully vet investments before proceeding and avoid prohibited transactions.

As it’s illegal to use an SDIRA to buy and sell personal residences, as well as nontraditional investments often being less liquid than stocks and exchange-traded funds – this may result in longer wait times to access funds in case they’re needed quickly – plus these assets may come with additional expenses for storage, insurance and appraisal that might not exist with more traditional investments.


When investing in a self-directed IRA, it’s essential to remember that you are accountable for its decisions. An SDIRA allows you to diversify your retirement savings portfolio through investments across a wide variety of assets; however, some investments could prove risky.

The IRS does not approve of purchases you can make with an SDIRA, such as real estate, promissory notes and collectibles. If you violate their rules, they could void your account and require all money be withdrawn as well as paying a tax bill.

Fraudsters may utilize SDIRAs to sell fraudulent investments, so be wary of brand new investment companies with unrealistic returns, or claims of unrealistic returns claiming third-party oversight is lacking.


Self-directed IRAs provide greater investment flexibility. These accounts permit individuals to invest in assets like real estate or promissory notes that typically aren’t permitted in traditional brokerage firm-held IRAs.

These types of assets may offer higher returns than stocks but involve more risk; should any asset lose value, an individual could potentially forfeit retirement savings.

Additionally, the IRS prohibits certain activities within an IRA account and if someone commits a prohibited transaction they can face serious hefty penalties – therefore it’s essential that a custodian carefully vet investments to ensure compliance with any restrictions placed upon prohibited transactions rules.

Raymond Banks Administrator
Raymond Banks is a published author in the commodity world. He has written extensively about gold and silver investments, and his work has been featured in some of the most respected financial journals in the industry. Raymond\\\'s expertise in the commodities market is highly sought-after, and he regularly delivers presentations on behalf of various investment firms. He is also a regular guest on financial news programmes, where he offers his expert insights into the latest commodity trends.

Categorised in: