Is it Better to Have an IRA Or a Roth IRA?

Is it better to have an IRA or a Roth IRA

Which IRA or Roth makes more sense depends largely on your anticipated tax bracket in retirement. Those expecting lower tax rates may prefer traditional IRAs which provide upfront tax benefits as well as potential deductions in the future.

People expecting to fall within higher tax brackets may benefit from opening a Roth account, which allows post-tax contributions and tax-free withdrawals in retirement. Both types of accounts can be found through banks, brokerage firms, life insurance companies and robo-advisors.


An Individual Retirement Account (IRA) does not owe taxes upon withdrawals; however, early withdrawal of Roth IRA funds before age 59 1/2 incurs a 10% penalty from the IRS; with certain exceptions such as permanent disability, first home purchase or high medical costs this penalty may be waived.

Consider whether or not your expected tax bracket in retirement will be lower or higher than it is now. If it does, a traditional IRA could make more sense since contributions qualify for tax deductions now, providing tax-deferred investment growth, with withdrawal taxes due upon withdrawals in retirement. Alternatively, Roth accounts offer tax-free withdrawals with benefits to heirs; however there are income restrictions when contributing. For self-employed workers looking for additional tax breaks they could set up an Simplified Employee Pension IRA which also makes contributions tax deductible – self-employed can establish a Simplified Employee Pension (SEP IRA), which also counts towards tax deductions now.


IRAs may help your money grow more rapidly than if it were held in a taxable account and may provide greater access to investments than employer-sponsored retirement plans such as 401(k).

However, withdrawals from an IRA account must adhere to certain rules. If you withdraw funds before meeting the five-year rule and owing income taxes on them as income distribution, income taxes must still be paid on any earnings taken out. Roth IRAs do not impose such restrictions but earnings still need to be reported and taxed upon upon distribution from them.

SEP and SIMPLE IRA withdrawals may also be subject to certain restrictions, as these accounts are designed for self-employed individuals and small-business owners who don’t have access to a company-sponsored retirement plan like 401(k). Employees contribute using taxable income while investments grow tax deferred until you withdraw them in retirement and are then taxed as ordinary income – these restrictions are intended to prevent people using these accounts for emergency savings or financing business ventures.


As you explore various brokerages or robo-advisors that provide an IRA, make sure they offer investment options that align with your personal financial goals and risk tolerance. It is also important to keep fees charged by each account in mind as fees can quickly add up over time and diminish overall earnings in an account.

People who are self-employed or own small businesses should consider opening an SEP or SIMPLE IRA as an asset protection strategy. These plans allow owners to contribute funds on behalf of their business tax-deductibly; investments grow tax-free until withdrawals must be taxed as income in retirement.

Roth IRAs may be an attractive retirement savings solution for people who believe their tax bracket will increase as they near retirement. Withdrawals made after meeting certain requirements – age 59 1/2 or five years ownership, for example – allow withdrawals without incurring taxes or penalties, providing valuable relief against inflationary pressures that erode value over time.


Keep a close eye on all fees you incur to ensure a healthy retirement savings plan. Many IRA providers impose an account maintenance fee which should be disclosed in your initial paperwork; others may charge transaction fees every time you buy or sell stocks, ETFs or mutual funds; this amount can differ significantly.

If your tax bracket will decrease after retirement, a Roth IRA could provide maximum after-tax savings; but for those expecting tax reductions from traditional IRAs may offer up-front tax advantages.

If you plan to invest a significant amount into your Roth IRA, it makes sense to find an online broker offering a range of low-cost investments at reasonable fees – for instance Vanguard offers over 200 commission-free ETFs and mutual funds, along with a user-friendly robo-advisor that lets you tailor your portfolio based on risk analysis and financial goals.

Raymond Banks Administrator
Raymond Banks is a published author in the commodity world. He has written extensively about gold and silver investments, and his work has been featured in some of the most respected financial journals in the industry. Raymond\\\'s expertise in the commodities market is highly sought-after, and he regularly delivers presentations on behalf of various investment firms. He is also a regular guest on financial news programmes, where he offers his expert insights into the latest commodity trends.

Categorised in: