Tax Benefits and Risks of Selling for a Loss in an IRA
IRS rulings provide clarity as to the application of the wash-sale rule to IRAs. This regulation prohibits investors from selling shares at a loss and purchasing them back within a certain period to gain tax advantages.
Investors should consult with their financial advisor and tax professional in deciding the most tax-efficient use for their IRA balances.
Tax loss harvesting
Harvesting losses can not only generate real tax savings, but can also help investors rebalance their portfolios and lower the risk of investing in bad investments. But investors should remember that harvesting losses involves some risks; such as selling your loss position only when its price has fallen below your purchase cost; otherwise you risk incurring a significant capital loss upon selling.
Wash sale rules also pose a potential threat, disallowing deductions on shares purchased within 30 days before or after selling stock at a loss. Be wary if attempting to use them; IRS has become increasingly strict on this aspect.
IRS policies show far less generosity when it comes to investment losses in IRA accounts, since these don’t offer the same tax advantages as taxable brokerage accounts. Instead, an IRA owner must itemize deductions on Schedule A in order to claim their deductible investment loss as part of an itemized deduction claim.
Wash-sale rule
The wash-sale rule prevents investors from taking advantage of temporary drops in IRA investments by selling and repurchasing them; when this occurs, IRS disallows losses and adds the new cost basis as tax basis on any future gains from these transactions. It applies to stocks, mutual funds, ETFs and contracts and options to purchase substantially identical securities.
Investors risk violating the wash-sale rule if they sell and then repurchase an asset within 30 or 61 days from an involuntary sale, thus creating losses that generate losses for themselves or IRAs. It’s not possible for an investor to sell an IRA investment then purchase it in another account including retirement accounts.
Some traders may believe they can avoid the wash-sale rule by selling in their taxable account and then purchasing similar investments within an IRA, but this practice violates tax code regulations and could lead to penalties from the IRS.
Deductible loss
IRAs are intended to help your savings accumulate tax-deferred until withdrawal time, typically retirement. But investments may fluctuate in value and when this occurs it’s essential that you understand how your taxes may be impacted.
Before the Tax Cuts and Job Act was passed, individuals could take a loss deduction on all IRA investments of the same type by cashing out all accounts at once. Unfortunately, that tax provision has since been suspended by Congress and may never return by 2025.
At present, some investors have proposed that to avoid falling foul of the wash-sale rule they can sell stocks within their IRA and then purchase similar shares through another brokerage account – but this approach may lead to your loss deduction being lost. You can still protect your IRA investment portfolio against losses by diversifying and investing in suitable securities, with regular rebalancing being performed and working with a financial professional on aligning it to meet your goals.
Closing out an IRA
An IRA is an excellent way to save for retirement, but when investments lose value it can be challenging to manage. Historically, tax breaks were available if your losses exceeded 2% of AGI when itemizing deductions; however, due to Tax Cuts and Jobs Act changes this provision has been suspended until 2025.
If your IRA account has lost money, there is still hope. Without incurring penalty fees, you can close out or transfer to an annuity that won’t fluctuate with market fluctuations, like a fixed index annuity – this option lets you keep the investment but instead earn interest based on an index like S&P 500 instead of stock markets. Consult a financial professional and tax expert before closing it out to ensure a successful outcome.
Categorised in: Blog