Tax Benefits of Selling For a Loss in an IRA
Losses in an IRA can have a dramatic impact on your investment goals due to how the IRS treats losses within your retirement account differently from what they treat outside it.
Tax-loss selling may seem like an obvious strategy in your taxable account, but is it right for your IRA holdings? Here are a few things to keep in mind before selling for a loss in an IRA.
1. You will have to pay taxes on the gain.
If you sell at a loss in an IRA, any profits earned will be considered income and taxed at your ordinary tax rate. But you could reduce your tax burden with the wash-sale rule: this rule prohibits selling an investment for a loss and then purchasing it back within a 61-day period within another taxable account – thus mitigating tax exposure in both cases.
IRAs provide tax-deferred growth until withdrawals take place, when earnings and capital gains may be taxed at either your marginal tax bracket or, if held longer than one year, at long-term capital gains rates.
Nondeductible IRA accounts and traditional IRAs that have been funded for many years cannot recognize losses because their contributions were post-tax and did not receive a deduction at the time of contribution. Furthermore, in order to claim losses in an IRA account of the same type for deduction purposes.
2. You will have to pay a penalty.
Investors selling for a loss in an IRA typically can no longer claim it as part of their taxable income, however before Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, losses were deductable up to 2% of adjusted gross income on Schedule A as miscellaneous itemized deductions.
Under the new law, IRA losses are only deductible when all nondeductible IRA accounts are cashed out and combined into one single account, since nondeductible IRA accounts only offer tax deferral for contributions made into them and not any gains or losses accruing within.
Investors can utilize IRA investments to generate investment income and diversify their portfolio, but it’s crucial they understand how these assets change value over time. If one asset class suffers a decrease, rebalancing is essential in protecting overall value of an IRA account and taking losses can save on taxes down the line.
3. You will have to pay a fee.
Although traditional or Roth IRA accounts allow traders to trade like any taxable brokerage account, they have some limitations. Namely, any losses in your IRA won’t reduce the taxes you must pay when withdrawing distributions (whether lump sums or income-based payments). An exception exists only if all your IRA assets have an after-tax balance (called basis) above current market value.
However, you should keep the wash-sale rule in mind before selling for a loss in an IRA account. This rule states that selling investments at a loss and then purchasing “substantially similar” ones within 61 days would violate this rule and create capital losses which are ineligible for tax deduction.
4. You will have to reinvest the loss.
Tax loss harvesting can be an excellent strategy to optimize your tax situation over the long run, yet it should be remembered that using losses from IRA accounts may present challenges.
IRAs are tax-sheltered accounts designed to help individuals save for retirement. Investors can use an IRA to invest in stocks, bonds, ETFs and mutual funds; tax advantages for this strategy can include contributions being tax-deductible while earnings remain tax-deferred until withdrawal in retirement.
As part of your IRA, this means that it is not permitted for you to sell investments at a loss and then immediately buy them back within a year (unless using illegal wash sale techniques). Instead, any losses must be reinvested in another asset which fulfills your investing goals – another reason to keep meticulous records on all investment transactions and associated transaction costs.
Categorised in: Blog