What Happens When You Sell for a Loss in an IRA?
Investments may fluctuate in value from time to time, yet investors typically are able to recover through their taxable brokerage accounts. But IRAs offer different opportunities.
Typically, investment losses in an IRA can only be recognized when your distributions have fallen below your basis and there are no more bases left for claim.
The IRS may disallow the loss
An uncertain stock market can quickly cause assets held within your individual retirement account (IRA) to decrease in value, yet that doesn’t have to mean disaster: in fact, taking advantage of losses could prove advantageous.
Tax loss harvesting is an investment strategy used in taxable accounts to offset gains, while distributions from IRAs are treated as ordinary income and should therefore not be harvested as tax losses.
Under Revenue Ruling 2008-5, to claim a loss on an IRA investment you must withdraw its balance within 30 days before or after sale and buy it back within 61 days (61-day window). Furthermore, any miscellaneous itemized deduction must be claimed on Schedule A of Form 1040 with its associated adjusted gross income limit applied; and use must take place during the year in which loss occurs.
You’ll have to pay taxes on the gain
Rebalancing your portfolio can help ensure that investments don’t experience sudden value drops over time, helping ensure they’re spread evenly among asset classes, economic sectors, and geographical regions.
When selling stocks at a loss in a taxable account, those losses are tax-deductible against gains and regular income (to an extent). But to deduct an IRA stock loss you must close and distribute cash distributions and itemize deductions and report them on Schedule A.
Unfortunately, tax-deferred vehicles such as IRAs or 401(k)s don’t allow you to deduct losses when taking distributions for anything other than investing (like purchasing a home or starting a business). Therefore it is vital that a plan be put in place in order to avoid early distribution penalties when necessary.
You’ll have to close the account
Investment losses are inevitable; however, when they occur in your retirement account they can be particularly distressing. This is especially true if you have substantial contributions over time that have built up into an IRA account as an original nondeductible basis for its initial value.
Unfortunately, the IRS doesn’t extend much mercy to IRA investors when it comes to investing losses. To claim your loss in an IRA account, all funds (and therefore basis) must be withdrawn and itemized deductions on Schedule A; any such gain won’t qualify as tax-deductible benefits and may also be limited by alternative minimum taxes.
Planning ahead and resisting temptation to sell investments when they dip is of the utmost importance in order to reach long-term financial goals and build retirement savings that you will appreciate in future years. Don’t allow short-term market fluctuations derail you; save for retirement now if necessary! You will thank yourself later.
You’ll have to itemize deductions
Your IRA assets may fluctuate in value over time; that’s part of investing. What matters is having a long-term plan with appropriate investment selection based on your risk tolerance.
Your gains and losses from an IRA will generally only be taxed when withdrawing them upon retirement; until then, these taxes remain deferred.
Your IRA investment losses can help lower your taxable income in the year of their sale, provided they are claimed as miscellaneous itemized deductions on Schedule A of your tax return and total at least 2% of adjusted gross income.
At first glance, meeting this requirement can be challenging, which is why many IRA owners forgo selling stocks even when their account has fallen below water. Instead, they prefer waiting until retirement and withdrawing money free of a 10% penalty tax penalty tax – though this may not always be the best strategy.
Categorised in: Blog