What is the Greatest Disadvantage of an Equity-Index Annuity?
Index annuities may not be suitable for everyone, but they can add significant value to a retirement investment portfolio if evaluated carefully. There are some key points to keep in mind when making the evaluation of such products.
These restrictions include participation rates, caps and yield-spread cost factors; in addition to high fees that could significantly diminish returns.
Guaranteed Minimum Returns
Due to low yields, many investors are drawn to equity index annuities because they promise “stock investing with guardrails.” Their returns tend to be limited and often include participation rate/spread/margin fees which reduce index-linked returns by subtracting.
Contracts often exclude dividends paid out by constituents of an index; these constitute an important element of its overall return.
Contract holders typically do not buy stocks when purchasing an indexed annuity; rather they pay premiums to an insurance company which may then be used to cover commissions and expenses, including potentially significant fees that reduce potential growth of their annuity. Furthermore, withdrawals from indexed annuities are taxed as ordinary income rather than capital gains and could make these products less appealing than alternatives; financial planners can help ensure investors make an unbiased comparison among various choices available to them.
Limited Growth Potential
Equity-indexed annuities also limit how much growth you can achieve due to floors and caps on annuity contracts – these represent maximum losses you may experience and the maximum interest the annuity will credit back into your account annually, respectively.
Assuming your index goes up by 10% but your annuity only participates at 70%, only 7% of that increase would be credited back into your annuity; meaning you cannot reap all of its advantages even when there is a significant market upswing.
Financial experts tend to hold different views about EIAs. Although these investments provide some protection from investment risk, their limited returns and fees that reduce returns make them not the optimal solution for all investors.
Cap Rates
Many indexed annuities feature a participation rate or interest rate spread that caps growth potential. These rates are included in their contract specifications and determine how much of each index increase will be credited back to your account annually – for instance if an index increases by 20% but your annuity only offers 75% participation, only 7% would be added back into your account (75% x 20%).
Equity-indexed annuities offer investors many advantages, with principal and credited interest guaranteed against loss by an insurance company – something investors look for in investment products – but at the price of limited growth potential.
Fees
Before investing, it’s essential to fully comprehend all fees associated with equity-indexed annuities, such as cap rates, participation rates and spread fees. Failure to understand these aspects could significantly decrease your overall return potential.
Insurance companies typically assess surrender fees on index annuity withdrawals prior to age 59.5; these could range anywhere from 10% or higher and serve to cover annuity expenses and/or sales agent commission.
Index annuities are complex investments, and should only be considered by investors who possess an in-depth understanding of their risks, such as their limited growth potential. Before making your final decision, be sure to seek multiple opinions from financial experts before taking action.
Categorised in: Blog